Unexpected Points

Unexpected Points

The Browns have been lucky, and they’re going to make the playoffs

The Data Debunk: The Cleveland Browns have six game-winning drives, will that hold up the rest of the season?

Kevin Cole's avatar
Kevin Cole
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid
Browns get another fourth-quarter comeback, defeat Texans 27-24 - NBC Sports

THE CLAIM

In Week 10, Deshaun Watson and the Cleveland Browns trailed the Houston Texans 17-0 and won 27-24. They have gone 6-4, they are in the AFC wild-card mix, and every win has come by 3 or 4 points, with a Watson-led go-ahead drive in the fourth quarter of each.

But the Browns have been outscored this season (-32 point differential), and have averaged slightly lower yards per play than opponents (5.1 to 5.2).

The idea is that this is who they are: a team that finds a way late, and should be trusted to keep doing it and make the playoffs.

Has the scoreboard been telling the truth about this team, or running ahead of it?

THE VERDICT: PARTIAL DEBUNK

The Browns’ 6-4 record doesn’t match their play. The Browns have fewer Pythagorean expected wins from the points they have scored and allowed, and my adjusted scores also see them as having gotten a little lucky. They have ranked 23rd in net EPA per play and 25th in offensive efficiency.

But the wins happened, and several of them were earned, and they count towards making the playoffs. With the state of the AFC right now, the Browns have as good of a chance as any of the non-elite teams competing to make the playoffs.

THE EVIDENCE

Adjusted scores start from EPA and success rate, take out fumble-recovery luck, down-weight special-teams scores, and drop garbage time, then turn each game’s margin into a win probability.

Looking across the NFL, this is how teams compare by expected wins (based on adjusted scores) and actual.

Actual wins versus expected wins from adjusted scores, 2026 through Week 10, with the Browns highlighted

Looking at the specific games played, the Browns deserved four wins so far this season, with a little higher 4.7 expected wins using calculated win probabilities on each game. The adjusted scores have favored them against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, the Baltimore Ravens, the Tennessee Titans, and the Texans. The wins over the Carolina Panthers and the Pittsburgh Steelers at home were coin flips. They have lost to the Jacksonville Jaguars, the New York Jets, the Steelers on the road, and the New Orleans Saints, and the adjusted scores agreed with all four.

The Browns’ -32 point differential overstates how bad they have actually been. Two losses, 10-34 at the Jaguars and 6-27 at the Steelers, account for 45 of the 51 points they have been outscored by in defeats. By adjusted scores, the road loss to the Steelers was 19-29, still a clear loss, just not a 21-point one. Their adjusted point differential is -20, better than -32, but still the profile of a below-average team.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Kevin Cole.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Kevin · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.