Unexpected Points

Unexpected Points

Joe Burrow is having the best quarterback season ever

The Data Debunk: Joe Burrow is on a heater and appears to be running away with the MVP award. How does his season compare to the greatest ever?

Kevin Cole's avatar
Kevin Cole
Nov 20, 2026
∙ Paid
Bengals' Joe Burrow surges ahead of Josh Allen as NFL MVP favorite - Los  Angeles Times

THE CLAIM

Through nine games, Joe Burrow has 2,795 passing yards (first per game), 27 passing touchdowns (first), 6 interceptions (ninth lowest rate), a 74.7% completion rate (first) and a 117.7 passer rating (first). Burrow has been particularly hot recently, averaging 380 passing yards and four touchdowns over his last three games.

An argument has bubbled up that is trending on X on whether he’s having the greatest quarterback season ever. Are we too focused on the hot streak or is Burrow really aligned to have a historic season?

THE VERDICT: LEAN DEBUNK

Burrow is having a historically elite run, but the best-season case doesn’t hold up. Touchdowns are his strongest statistical category, with 27 through nine games ranking eighth among quarterback seasons since 1999. With 2,795 passing yards, he only ranks 34th.

Turning to advanced metrics like expected points added (EPA), Burrow ranks an elite 12th of 884 quarterback seasons since 1999 in total EPA through nine games, but 38th in EPA per dropback. Adjusting for era, his efficiency ranking falls even further.

The last five games have been historic, and they account for 78.7% of his total EPA. If you believe the recent trend is more predictive than the total season so far, Burrow could make a run at the record books. But historically, the shorter the time frame, the less predictive the sample.

THE EVIDENCE

The touchdown total is where Burrow’s case looks best. His 27 are 8th through nine games, and the chart below compares his pace with the 20 best passing touchdown seasons since 1999.

Cumulative passing touchdowns by game played for Joe Burrow in 2026 against the 20 best touchdown seasons since 1999

Peyton Manning in 2013 and Tom Brady in 2007 each had 33 touchdowns through nine games, and Patrick Mahomes in 2018 had 29, all ahead of Burrow’s 27.

Looking at passing yards, Burrow’s 2,795 ranks 34th through nine games, and he’s a bit towards the lower half for nine-game pace among the top-20 yardage seasons.

Burrow isn’t that far off of Drew Brees’ record-breaking 2011 campaign, when he had 3,004 passing yards through nine games. But Brees went absolutely insane down the stretch, averaging 353 yards per game in his last seven games, better than his first-nine pace of 334 yards per.

Typically, passing production slows during the season, and Burrow won’t have the ideal weather conditions that Brees enjoyed. The New Orleans Saints played all but one of their final seven games in domes, with the exception at the Tennessee Titans at a relatively balmy 41 degrees with modest wind.

The best test for “greatest” seasons should use the best metric for value: expected points added.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Kevin Cole.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Kevin · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.